DFWChild / Articles / Family Life / Kids / Playtime: Should You Always Say “Yes” to Playing With Your Kids?
Mom avoiding play playing and playtime with son

Playtime: Should You Always Say “Yes” to Playing With Your Kids?

should you feel guilty about asking your child to play independently?

Your work takes too long,” my 6-year-old son informed me recently. I looked up at him from my laptop, where I was editing content for the upcoming DFWChild issue. I knew where this was going. “You need a job that takes less time so you can play with me more,” he continued, going on to suggest alternate occupations—home remodeling, perhaps?—that he thought would give me more time for Nerf battles and space wars. If he had his way, I’d be a full-time playmate.

Truth be told, I try to be as close to that as possible. But it can be exhausting.

A lot of moms deal with the “Play with me!” refrain. It became even more common during social distancing, with kids cooped up in the house and friends confined to theirs.

First things first: We adore our kids and want them to be happy. But sometimes, child’s play is the opposite of what you want to do at that given moment. Maybe you’ve had a full day of work or have been running endless errands. Perhaps you were anxious to sit down with a book or watch your favorite show to regain a little sanity. Answering your child’s “Will you play with me?” affirmatively might push you past your limit. Answering, “No, not now,” may fill you with guilt. So what’s the right answer?

Let Go of Guilt

I’m a single mom of an only child. I don’t have my son 100% of the time, so I feel like I should save all my “me time” for days he is with his dad. And he doesn’t have another kid at home to play with. But in chatting with experts, I was reminded that my kiddo doesn’t benefit if I’m completely burned out.

“It’s important to model self-care, the idea that I need down time and to relax,” says Dr. Kim Mangham, a pediatrician at Cook Children’s Pediatrics – Keller Parkway. “Parents need to understand that they don’t have to do it all.”

As it turns out, saying no from time to time is beneficial not only for parents but also for their offspring.

“It’s good for kids to have downtime and even be bored,” says Dr. Alice Ann Holland, a pediatric neuropsychologist who practices in Dallas and is affiliated with Children’s Health and UT Southwestern. “Boredom develops frustration tolerance, emotional regulation—the ability to manage and work through a negative feeling—and opportunities for imagination and creativity. Children will have to think to themselves, Mom can’t play. How do I deal with that? What do I do?

Parents can facilitate play without participating themselves; it’s all about creating the right environment and opportunities. “Especially in the current situation, when perhaps children are doing virtual learning or forgoing their regular playdates, you want to create a space conducive to free play,” Holland says. “Maybe move all your furniture to the side in one room so kids can run around, hula hoop, build cushion forts and so on.”

As she indicates, the tools for play don’t need to be complicated—high-tech toys and apps are not required. That’s not to say some screen time isn’t OK. “It’s absolutely fine to say, ‘I want you to play on your iPad for an hour while I watch my show,’” says Mangham. But hour-after-hour, nonstop screen time in place of free play? Not a good idea.

“Just because we’re still social distancing doesn’t mean children’s brains stop growing and developing,” points out Holland. “There’s literature showing increased screen time can have negative effects on cognitive skills, language and academic performance.”

That means children should, as often as possible, go back to that seemingly archaic world before everyone had a smartphone in hand. “Kids need puzzles, blocks, sidewalk chalk, pots and pans, everyday household things,” notes Mangham. “These days, elementary kids are coming into school with fine motor delays because they’ve been spending so much time on devices. They just need the basics, and they’ll use their imaginations.”

Mangham recalls hearing her own children laughing and getting along while they were upstairs on their own. She found them building towers and a moat out of sheets, complete with pretend alligators. “They were entertaining themselves,” she says. “It’s not our job as parents to constantly entertain our children.”

And when we do?

“It sends kids a message that the world revolves around them,” says Holland, “and that can lead to poor adjustment.”

Not Now, But Later

So, fellow moms, you get the experts’ blessing to say no—but not every time. “If at all possible, the best response isn’t really ‘no’; it’s ‘Not now, but later,’” suggests Holland. “And then follow through.”

Like many things, playing with your kid is about quality over quantity. Experts say when you’re giving your child time, also give them your full attention. Mangham advises parents to leave their cell phones in another room. You should also give your child wide latitude in choosing what to play. “They do well when you give them control,” reveals Mangham, “and they don’t have control over much.”

That means going along even when you find the activity tedious. For me, that’s playing video games with my son. (Holland told me I was “a saint” for doing this. That’s all the parenting validation I need in life.) Of course, some gentle redirecting is allowed, but for the most part, let your child have his say as long as the activity is appropriate.

“If your child has waited patiently, they’ve been playing quietly, then it’s their time,” says Mangham. “Focus 100% on them. And you’re modeling good behavior. They sacrificed; now you’re sacrificing. So you do it, even if you’d rather pull your eyes out than play that board game or read that book again.”

(Play)time Management

Even if it is quality over quantity, the quantity question remains. How often should we be playing with our kids, and for how long? As you might expect, there aren’t universal answers.

“Even a brief play session can be impactful if you’re really engaged,” shares Holland. “It really depends on the child and the situation. I’d be especially aware of this, though, with children who don’t have siblings—which means fewer opportunities for collaborative play. Some only children are fine playing on their own all day, but particularly during this time when playdates may be limited, parents should try to make up for the lack of a built-in playmate as best they can.”

Holland suggests a loose schedule for joint play to manage young expectations. Typically, two short play sessions a day work well, she says. “Maybe you do 30 minutes in the morning and 30 minutes in the afternoon. At the end, you can tell your child, ‘Now Mommy has to work, but we’ll do it again later.’ Whatever you do, try to stick to the schedule. Things come up, but when they do, reschedule the playtime. And add more minutes to the rescheduled time if you can. It’s letting your child know, ‘I’m setting aside time for you. You are important to me.’”

Kids Are Capable

For the average child, there’s not a risk of emotional damage when you have to deny their request to play. “The disappointment of Mom saying no every now and then will not be harmful to their long-term mental health,” says Holland. “It can build character, resilience and healthy independence and resourcefulness.”

And you might be surprised at what your kid is already able to accomplish behind the frequent badgering for you to “come here.”

“You really can just talk to them and explain that they have to be patient,” Mangham says. “Give them a standard to rise to. Kids will resist what they’re not used to or what they don’t want, but they will step up and do it. Children are a heck of a lot smarter and more capable than society gives them credit for.”


Rules of Engagement

Expert tips for getting the most out of playtime—and managing your child’s expectations

  • If you can’t play now, set a time when you can. When you need to delay playing with your child, it helps for them to be aware that there’s a defined end to their wait. You might set a timer and ask your child to play on her own until it goes off, and then you’ll play blocks together.
  • Be engaged in a way that works for your child. “Some kids like you to ask if you can play with them, because it shows you’re really interested in being part of it,” says pediatric neuropsychologist Dr. Alice Ann Holland. “Other children may prefer you to ask questions about what they’re doing and wait for an invitation to join—just show your openness to that by joining them on the floor, for example.”
  • Give your child tools to express their emotions. “When you can’t play with your child, it makes for a good opportunity to engage about their feelings,” says Dr. Kim Mangham, a pediatrician. “Ask them, ‘Did it make you sad when Mom couldn’t play earlier?’ Give them the words and help them know it’s a safe environment to share their feelings.”

Playing Solo

Use these recommendations to encourage independent play:

  • Put half or a third of your child’s toys away at a time. “Novelty can be exciting for kids,” says Holland. “If the toy is gone for a while and then comes back, it’s suddenly more fun to play with that toy again.”
  • Send them outside (safely, of course). “Kids thrive outside. It calms moods, improves behaviors and gives them physical and social-emotional benefits,” shares Mangham.
  • Get natural. “A lot of kids, especially those who live in apartments, are missing interaction with the natural environment,” says Holland. “Give them the opportunity to play with water and sand. It’s messy but great for cognitive development and creativity.”

Image courtesy of iStock.